Which is better pic?

[Campaign 0]

Okay, can't decide which of these two is the better pic... Please put your opinions down...

[KARMANN 0]

Second one. because theres no car comming into the shot and its not squinty.

 

Cheers Fraser

[Furkz 0]

def 2nd one,,its straight

[DanA 0]

Very nice motor! is it yours ??

 

BTW: 2nd pic for sure

[A20 LEE 0]

i'll go for the first one. Has more life to it for me.

[Joe M 0]

Just now id say second one, but if someone could p-shop the first one straight I may change my mind.

[LarryDuff 0]

The second one draws the eye to the car more.

[Phil K 0]

Deffo the second one but neither of them are a patch on your MK1 Golf shot 8)

[Musicman 0]

Just now id say second one, but if someone could p-shop the first one straight I may change my mind.

 

cross-posting my crop from No-Rice, but hey, you did ask :)

 

[Campaign 0]

You see, I reckon the first shot as it's got more life to it, second one's a bit dead for me...

[Campaign 0]

Just now id say second one, but if someone could p-shop the first one straight I may change my mind.

 

cross-posting my crop from No-Rice, but hey, you did ask :)

 

 

Yeah, that's kinda good. Haven't had time to do any cropping or anything on these pics yet. From a "composition" point of view it was pure accident as I had spent about 3 minutes waiting for people to move from around the front of the rallye and then just as I was taking it some bloke drives past in front.... But then, looking back I kinda prefered the original.

[GIXXERUK 0]

the first pic , it's more vibrant , although it disturbs me that they are parked so close esp with it being lhd

[Supercharged Junkie 0]

I`ll say the fifth pic just to be annoying :iamwithstupid:

[theRuler 0]

the first one. with the golf zooming in its a good pic

[Bally 0]

2nd pic..

[GTFCTIM 0]

2nd pic

[dinkus 10]

the first pic , it's more vibrant , although it disturbs me that they are parked so close esp with it being lhd

 

Yeah good point, I'd have asked them to move a bit, then the first pic would be the best ;)

[belfastfumanchu 0]

Neither is a good pic in my opinion, but the first one isnt as bad as second.

[Campaign 0]

Neither is a good pic in my opinion, but the first one isnt as bad as second.

 

That wasn't the question, I know they're not particularly good pics from a composition or technical point of view, BUT it's more which is more "pleasing to the eye..."

[dinkus 10]

...or this?

 

(can you tell I'm bored?? :lol: )

[Kevin Bacon 5]

Yep, Dinkus' effort is best because it actually puts the Rallye into context. The other two are just two random photos of a bunch of cars and means nothing to anyone except the snapper.

 

Erm, and Dinkus, how do you do that B&W background trickery? Can paint shop pro do that?

[dinkus 10]

Yep, Dinkus' effort is best because it actually puts the Rallye into context. The other two are just two random photos of a bunch of cars and means nothing to anyone except the snapper.

 

Erm, and Dinkus, how do you do that B&W background trickery? Can paint shop pro do that?

 

:lol: I wasn't sure if anyone had noticed the missing cars... that took ages!

 

And the B&W thing can be done fairly easily...

 

Cut round the car (I find the point to point tool works best) and copy it.

 

Convert the image to greyscale and then back to full colour (the picture will stay greyscale, but you then have a full colour pallate to use again)

 

Paste the car back on top :)

[Henny 0]

you could also then mess about with the scale of the Rallye and make it appear that the other car is about to hit it... or is that just my warped mind at work again?!? :oops: :lol:

[Graham_E 0]

you could also then mess about with the scale of the Rallye and make it appear that the other car is about to hit it... or is that just my warped mind at work again?!? :oops: :lol:

 

 

think its just your warped mind again lol. first pic that dinkus did if we're counting them if not pic 1

[Campaign 0]

As I said, I wasn't asking what you thought of the photo, just which one was better...